Home/Math/4-Digit Subtraction with Regrouping
Christmas 4-digit subtraction with regrouping grade 4
Mystery Detective

4-Digit Subtraction with Regrouping

Mystery Detective Worksheets · Grades 3–6 · Christmas Theme

3rd grade math4th grade mathGrade 3Grade 4Grade 5Grade 6Answer keys included

Instant PDF download after checkout. Prefer TPT? It's there too.

Bundle & save, automatically: $12+ saves 10% $25+ saves 20% $50+ saves 30%Mix any cases. The discount shows at checkout.
Get it on TPT ↗
Self-checkingEvery right answer clears a suspect. A wrong answer matches nobody.
No prepPrint and go, or share the link for digital rooms.
Sub-day readyClear instructions and full answer keys.

Inside the case file

4 digit subtraction with regrouping Christmas math worksheets for 3rd grade and 4th grade, five Mystery Detective math cases with borrowing across four columns on every page. No prep December math activities with full answer keys, print and go, for math centers, early finishers, homework, morning work and sub plans. Four digit subtraction with regrouping is the biggest borrowing of the year, and this pack gives 3rd grade and 4th grade students a school Christmas reason to practice it. It is December math that runs as a math center, a sub plan or a homework set, and every CSI Mini Mystery Detective page is self-marking.

Keep this one for the week before the break, because a class can run these CSI Mini Mystery Detective math cases without you at the front and a substitute has nothing to explain. Students subtract, match each answer to a suspect and cross that name off, so the marking is student-led even on the biggest borrowing of the year.

The Cases

  1. Missing Marshmallows - the marshmallows disappear overnight
  2. Teachers Christmas Lunch - who cooked the staffroom lunch
  3. Christmas Presents - who gets to unwrap first
  4. Missing Candy Canes - stripped straight off the tree
  5. Christmas Star - who puts the star on top

What's Inside

  • Five case files, each with a crime sheet and its own lineup of suspects
  • Four digit subtraction with regrouping on every page
  • Borrowing across four columns, the hardest subtraction at this level
  • Each answer matches one suspect and no other, so the page checks itself
  • A full answer key for every case
  • Print and go: no cutting, no laminating, nothing to prepare

What Is a CSI Mini Mystery Detective?

A CSI Mini Mystery Detective is a printable case with a lineup of suspects, each carrying a number. The questions on the crime sheet produce those numbers, a correct answer strikes one suspect off, and the last name standing is the culprit. The elimination only works when the math is right, which is what makes these detective activities show up mistakes a page of math worksheets would hide.

When to Use This Resource

Four digit borrowing is the skill that most needs repetitions and least often gets them, and November and December is when the timetable has the least room for it. Five short cases fix both problems at once. Because one wrong borrow puts the wrong name in the frame, students trace the error back through the columns themselves instead of handing you the page.

It covers test prep, homework, math centers, morning work, early finishers, sub plans, homeschool lessons and spiral review, with a class, a small group or one student.

Grade Levels

Written for 3rd grade and 4th grade, where four digit subtraction sits in the standards. Fifth graders use it as a fluency refresher, and second graders take it once three digit borrowing is secure.

Why Teachers Love These Cases

  • Five pages on the hardest subtraction third and fourth graders meet
  • Students trace a wrong borrow back when the wrong name comes off
  • No prep in the busiest month of the year
  • Works with a whole class, a small group, partners, or one student alone

Love this resource?

Follow Kiwiland Education to discover more CSI Mini Mystery Detective cases, no-prep math activities, and detective-themed printables for elementary classrooms.

Follow Kiwiland Education on TPT ↗